The brain training industry generates over a billion dollars annually from people who believe that daily practice on cognitive mini-games will make them measurably smarter. Apps like Lumosity, BrainHQ, and Elevate have tens of millions of users. The implicit promise — train your brain like a muscle and watch your IQ climb — is enormously appealing.
The research tells a more complicated story. Not because cognitive training is useless, but because "getting better at brain training tasks" and "becoming genuinely more intelligent" are two very different things — and the evidence that commercial brain training apps achieve the second is considerably weaker than their marketing implies.
The Near Transfer Problem
When you practice any cognitive task repeatedly, you get better at it. Practice working memory tasks and your performance on those specific working memory tasks improves. Practice pattern recognition games and your pattern recognition speed on those specific games improves. This is near transfer — improvement on the trained task itself.
The question that matters is whether this improvement transfers to untrained cognitive tasks — whether getting better at a Lumosity memory game makes you better at remembering things in real life, or whether improving your score on a pattern recognition game improves your performance on an IQ matrix test you have never seen before. This is far transfer — and it is where the evidence becomes weak.
A landmark 2010 study published in Nature — one of the most rigorous examinations of commercial brain training to date — found that while participants showed significant improvement on the specific tasks they trained on, these gains did not transfer to untrained cognitive tasks. People got better at the games. They did not get smarter in any general sense.
A 2014 open letter signed by over 70 leading cognitive neuroscientists and psychologists stated that the scientific evidence for commercial brain training products improving general cognitive function or reducing cognitive decline was not strong. This was directed explicitly at the marketing claims of commercial brain training companies.
What About Working Memory Training?
The most extensively studied specific brain training approach is dual n-back training — a demanding working memory task that requires simultaneously tracking two sequences of stimuli and identifying when each matches what appeared n steps back. Early research suggested this training might improve fluid intelligence, generating significant excitement in the cognitive science community.
Subsequent meta-analyses and replication attempts have substantially deflated this excitement. The most rigorous studies find little to no transfer from dual n-back training to general fluid intelligence measures. Performance on the dual n-back task itself improves with practice — but this does not appear to translate meaningfully into higher IQ test scores or better real-world cognitive performance.
What Actually Does Improve Cognitive Performance?
This is where the research becomes genuinely useful rather than merely cautionary. Several interventions have stronger evidence for genuine cognitive benefit than commercial brain training apps.
Aerobic Exercise
Aerobic exercise is the single most robustly supported intervention for improving cognitive performance across multiple studies and meta-analyses. Regular aerobic exercise — running, cycling, swimming — increases brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), promotes neurogenesis in the hippocampus, and is associated with measurable improvements in memory, attention, and executive function. The effects are not dramatic in healthy young adults but are consistent and well-replicated. In older adults and those with cognitive impairments the effects are more pronounced.
Sleep Quality and Quantity
Chronic sleep restriction impairs virtually every domain of cognitive performance that IQ tests measure — working memory, processing speed, fluid reasoning, and attention. Restoring adequate sleep quantity and quality produces measurable cognitive improvements in people who were previously sleep-restricted — which is a large proportion of the adult population. If you are sleeping fewer than seven hours per night, fixing this will do more for your cognitive performance than any brain training app.
Learning New Complex Skills
Learning genuinely new and cognitively demanding skills — a new language, a musical instrument, a complex game like chess, a new programming language — appears to provide broader cognitive benefits than brain training games. The difference is that these activities require sustained engagement with novel complex material over long periods, building genuine new knowledge structures rather than training the same narrow cognitive operation repeatedly.
Formal Education and Intellectual Engagement
The single strongest environmental predictor of IQ score is years of formal education — each additional year of schooling is associated with an approximately 1–5 point increase in IQ score in large-scale studies. Sustained intellectual engagement — reading complex material, working through difficult problems, engaging with challenging ideas — builds the crystallized intelligence component of IQ continuously throughout life.
| Intervention | Evidence Quality | Real-World Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Commercial brain training apps | Weak | Improves trained tasks only |
| Dual n-back training | Mixed | Limited general transfer |
| Aerobic exercise | Strong | Broad cognitive benefit |
| Sleep optimisation | Strong | Large impact if sleep-deprived |
| Learning new complex skills | Good | Broader transfer than games |
| Reading and education | Strong | Builds crystallized IQ over time |
The Honest Bottom Line
Brain training apps will make you better at brain training apps. They will probably not make you meaningfully smarter in any general sense that transfers to your actual life. The evidence for commercial brain training products improving real-world cognitive function is not strong enough to justify the time investment compared to alternatives with better evidence bases.
If you genuinely want to improve your cognitive performance, the unsexy answer is also the evidence-based one: exercise regularly, sleep adequately, engage seriously with complex intellectual material, and invest in learning real skills in domains you care about. None of these are as frictionless as opening an app for ten minutes a day — which is precisely why the brain training industry exists.
Measure where you are right now
Before optimising your cognitive performance, know your baseline. The free IQ test gives you a full domain breakdown in 20 minutes.
Take the Free IQ Test →